Disclaimer

DISCLAIMER: All material provided for reference and research purposes only. No reproduction of images or text is permissible. If linking to any item on this blog, please site the source.
Showing posts with label letter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label letter. Show all posts

January 9, 2019

20158. The Arizona Miner, Prescott, Arizona Territory, February 1st, 1873. Letter from Camp Date Creek. (letter)

The Arizona Miner Prescott, Arizona Territory February 1st, 1873 Letter from Camp Date Creek. To the Editor of the Arizona Miner: Since I last wrote you, there has been numerous changes at Camp Date Creek. In the first place we have had a change in comm anding officers- Captain Henton, a fine officer and estimable gentleman, being sent on recruiting service, and Lieut. J.F. Trout being left in command, and as he is, at present, the only officer at the post, indeed he has his hands full- being comm anding officer, Q.M. and A.C.S. The next change has taken place in the medical department; Dr. La Baree being relieved, and in his stead we have Dr. Corbusier. The Indian department is in flourishing condition- nearly four hundred pets on the reserve and more expected. Mr. Brannan and staff are erecting a large building to be occupied by the Indian department, which, I suppose, will be finished in the course of a few days. Everyt hing, in fact, around the post looks lively; and it would surprise most any stranger, coming here, to see the teams, loaded with hay and wood, arriving here every day. “Ochoc ama” is expected with his braves. He has been outside the limits of the reserve for some time past, and has been seen within three miles of the post several times, and, I suppose, the next thing you here will be that he is playing “good Indian” again. Some of our scouts that went with Capt. Price have returned, and seem heap tired of playing soldier. OBSERVER.

January 8, 2019

20142, 20143. The Arizona Miner, Prescott, Arizona Territory, October 26th, 1872. From Camp Date Creek. (letter)

The Arizona Miner Prescott, Arizona Territory October 26th, 1872 From Camp Date Creek. A recent private letter from Camp Date Creek informs us that Lieut. Wm. J. Volkmar, 5th Cavalry, was making an excellent commanding officer. Mr. Beaty was filling his hay contract to the satisfaction of everybody. Mr. Gilson has gathered pretty good crops. Frank Murray, formerly of Prescott, was doing the agreeable at the post trader’s establishment. Not long since, a certain person at the post challenged another person to fight a duel. Challenged person accepted, named large sized six shooting pistols; five paces; to shoot at word; fire till one was killed. Rather brimstony and calculated to bring on shakes. Commandi ng officer heard this and set his face against it, so nobody fought and nobody was hurt Bueno. The Arizona Miner Prescott, Arizona Territory November 2nd, 1872 More Good News. Nine More Apache-Mohave Indians Suffer Death for their Crimes. (From the Miner Extra, of October 29th.) The military party which started from Camp Hualpai on the 21st inst., under command of General Crook, have returned home, after having killed nine Apache-Mohave Indians and captured and des troyed considerable quantities of Apache provender, arms, etc. The killing was done near the Santa Maria river, on the 25th inst. by troops under the immediate command of Captain Mason, 5th Cavalry, to whose energy and determination all friends of civilization are indebted for lessons taught the murderous savages of this section. Previous to striking the foe, Gen. Crook, with a few men, had struck out for Camp Date Creek, to see and have a talk with some Indians who said they desired peace. D.C. Moreland and George Hogle, from whom we have received the foregoing information, say that one Wallapai was killed by mist ake. His friends burned his body, gun, blankets, etc. Captains Montgomery and Adam led their companies. We rejoice over the fact that nine more murderers have met a just doom, and that General Crook’s plans are being so successf ully carried out. Since placing the foregoing in type, we have learned that our force consisted of portions of three Companies of the Fifth Cavalry— K, B, and C, Captains Mason, Montgomery and Adam; Lieutenants Schuyler and Michler, of same regiment; about 85 Wallapai Indians, guides and packers. Citizens D.C. Moreland, George Hogle and Jos. Fugit, took advantage of the movements of the expedition to prospect the country. The Apache-Mohaves were very wary and, but for the keen search made by the troops and friendly Indians, no Apache-Mohaves would have been found. The friendly Wallapai had either thrown off his distinguishing badge, or lost it, and to this fact is his death attributable. His friends did not like this portion of the performance, but became reconciled and well pleased after their demand of two horses in payment for the lost comrade, had been complied with. There are numerous other details, but we have neither time nor space to give them, and wiil close by tendering the thanks of our citizens to Gen. Crook, his officers and men, including the friendly Wallapais, for this, the latest article in a new and lasting Peace treaty soon to be made by General Crook.

20140, 20141. Letter written by 1st Lieutenant William J. Volkmar, commanding Co. "E" 5th Cavalry at Camp Date Creek, A.T. (letter)

The following letter written by 1st Lieutenant William 3. Volkmar, commandi ng Co. “E” 5th Cavalry at Camp Date Creek, AT, to his friend Stephen Perry Jocelyn— was copied from pages 170— 72 of “Mostly Alkali” by Stephen Perry Jocelyri II. Caidwell, Idaho: The Caxton Printers LTD., 1953. The letter refers to two major events in Arizona Territorial Military History. The August 29th, 1872 death of Captain Philip Dwyer, Co. “E” 5th Cavalry at Camp Date Creek, A.T. (who at the time of his death, was the only commissioned officer stationed at the post) and the tragic Camp Date Creek Incident of September 8th, 1872. Camp Date Creek, A.T. October 15th, 1872 My Dear Jocelyn: Your very welcome letter of Sept. 18th reached me last evening. It is, indeed, only too true that poor Stewart has fallen a victim to savage cruelty. He was on his way from Critteriden to Tucson as Judge Advocate of a Gen. C.M. to convene at the latter place. He rode on a small buckboard, accompanied by Corporal Black of “F” Co., 5th Cay. An escort was following behind in a wagon. Stewart got some distance ahead of the escort and was “jumped” in bjoad daylight by a band of a dozen Indians. He received five wounds and was shot, I am told, through both heart and brain. It was mercy that he was instantly killed, for Corporal Black was captured alive, carried off some distance and there brutally tortured before death put an end to his cruel sufferings. The escort coming up a little later, found poor Stewart’s body, stripped, plundered and mutilated. An officer reports, over his official signature, that he firmly believes the outrage to have been committed by the Camp Grant Indians, and he thinks a thorough search among them might disc over Stewart’s watch and class ring. The body of our poor friend was brought into Tucson and there buried with the last military honors. A thrill of horror has gone through the entire country and already blows of harsh retaliation have been struck by the troops. I would like greatly to write you at length about affairs in Arizona but I am very much pressed for time just now and can send you only these hastily scrawled lines. I was in the field when Captain Dwyer suddenly died here and a special disp atch was sent to me, Aug. 29th to proceed here immediately and take command of the post and “E” Company. I was quite alone here for weeks- had to inventory and take up every species of company, Q.M., C.S. and ordnance property and funds— an almost endless job, and at the same time had a terribly disordered state of Indian affairs to manage, which itself terminated finally in a desperate fight, right on the parade ground of the post. I was heartily glad when Capt. Henton’s company arrived here and I was relieved of part of my many and pressing duties. I am now commanding “E” Co., 5th Cay, and am also on duty settling up the public and private business of Capt. Dwyer, deceased, which last job will carry me up to December, at least, for he was so sick during the last months of his life that he could attend to nothing and his papers are all confused and incomplete.... Capt. Henton, who was stationed at Warner, is in command here and joins me in every good wish for your happiness... Your obedient servant, William J. Volkmar- 1st Lieutenant Company “E” 5th U.S. Cavalry.

January 6, 2019

20134. Prescott Yavapai Co. Arizona Octo. 4th 72. Sister Ellen, I have for sometime thought you may have forgotten me as I have not heard from you (letter)

Prescott Yavapai Co. Arizona Octo. 4” 72. Sister Ellen I have for sometime thought you may have forgotten me as I have not heard from you: well I dont know but that the fault may lie at my door but be it as it may I shall write you and thus remove the responsibility to some one else. My health is good and location the same as before. This part of the country affords nothing that would probably interest you but still what there is I’ll try and tell as you will see, in the papers before this comes to hand: the indians have been treated to that which they dont often get via, good sound threshings during the last ten days (57) fifty seven have been killed in two fights and possibly as many more wounded. They have had control of the territory long enough in fact they were very busy killing and stealing just as often an such so am pleased these Loring’s murderers have been brought to light they were Camp Date Creek indians as we supposed some of these are in the guard house and some were killed while trying to arrest them they drew their rations at the above named camp it was a free fight indians commenced first Gen’l. Crook got knocked down during the fracas. The war has actively commenced. The diamond business I think is a humbug gotten for speculation mining and prospecting is dull farmers have gathered their crops in and I think they are better than last year, and still are not extra good shooting affairs take place as usual, one man buried to day and one lynching done. Esther in fact you would pronounce the morals of Prescott below par. I hear that there has been a new arrival is it so I guess it is Miss Helen allows me to rest in ignorance as to what transpires at Snag maybe some one else so occupies her thoughts to my exclusion give my respects to, well young ladies in general Tom sr. and Tom junior and the rest. Respectfully from your brother Jesse A. Park I am in the Dry Store yet

20129, 20130, 20131, 20132, 20133. Office of the U.S. Ind. Agent, Camp Date Creek, A.T., October 1st, 1872, Superintendent of Indian Affairs, Arizona Territory, Prescott, A.T. (letter)

Office of the U.S. md. Agent Camp Date Creek, A.T. October 1st, 1872 Superintendent of Indian Affairs, Arizona Territory Prescott, A.T. Sir: I have the honor to submit the following Report of the condition of affairs at this Agency during the month of September 1872. In my report of the month preceding, I made known to you, that the Indians had during several weeks, suffered greatly from disease, and that they appeared much disheartened thereby, and that discontent and restlessness were manifested among them to a considerable extent. On the 1st day of the month, just closed, O-hat-che-com-a, Chief of the Apache Mojave tribe, applied to me for permission to leave the reservation, with a part of his band, for the period of thirty days: assigning as a reason for his request, that disease was making frightful havoc with his people, and that it was necessary that they should go to the mountains for recuperation. The conduct of this Chief, during his sojourn upon this reservation, had been, as I was informed highly exemplary; and upon consideration of the peculiar nature of the case, and believing that a change of scene and diet would operate bene— ficially upon the suffering sick of his people, I deemed it judicious to grant, with certain restrictions, his request. These restrictions were as follows: 1st.- That he was not to go further than one days journey from the reserve. 2nd.- That he was to go to a certain designated camping ground. 3rd.- That he was to report in person at the Agency, once in each seven days. 4th.- That he was to return with his band, if sent for, at any time, even before the lapse of the period named. And lastly. that he was to leave his brother as an hostage for the fulfillment of these conditions. After the Chief had left the reservation, it was discovered that the whole of his band (with the exception of his brother, and an Indian, who is known by the soubriquet of “Indian Jim”) had departed, and it was rumored that they did not intend to return. On the 5th day of the month, Jose Bacote and Charlie (the two Indians who had gone from this reservation to Washington with Gen. Howard) returned, and stated that the Superintendent of Indian Affairs would speedily arrive here, and that he wished to have a long talk with all the Indians. This, was made known to the Indians and on the following morning (the 6th ultimo), I informed Te—ye-ma-jor (brother of the absent Chief) and Indian Camp Date Creek, A.T. October 1st, 1872 Continued- Jim, that I desired them to go out, as guides, with one of my employees, to the camp of O-hat-che-com-a, to verify that that Chief had complied with my conditions; to find out the number of people in his camp, and generally, to learn how they were faring. This, Te-ye-ma-jor and Indian Jim promised to do, but when my messenger, had prepared himself for the ride, the Indians were nowhere to be found, and he was obliged to make the journey alone. He reports, that he found the camp, but that it had been entirely deserted by the Indians, a few days before. He followed their trail (which led in the direction of the Black Mesa) for about five miles, and then not having seen anything of them, he returned to the Agency. On that evening Capt. Byrne, accompanied by Iretaba, Chief of the Mojave tribe and two other Indians, arrived here, and on the following morning, the Indians on this reservation seemed much exorcised concerning the presence of Iretaba. It appears that there has heretofore, been much animosity existing between the bands of this reservation, and the band of Iretaba. In fact, the feud between them had grown to such proportions that at one time (some months ago), as I was inf ormed, the last mentioned band had sent a message to the Indians here of the following import; that if any of them came over to the Colorado Reservation, they would be killed, and I am also informed that our Indians returned a like hostile message to the band of Iretaba. It was then by no means singular that these Indians indulged in grave speculations as to why Iretaba had been called here, and that much excitement was manifested among them. This excitement was, in some measure, allayed, when, after I had brought together the Mojave Chief and some of our head men and required them to shake hands, Iretaba explained that he had come here merely because Gen. Crook was coming, and desired to meet, and have a talk with all good Indians. On the same morning, Te-ye—ma-jor and Indian Jim came in, and seemed particularly anxious to get possession of 0-hat—che- corn-a’s revolver, which had been left with the Blacksmith of the Post, for repairs. This, together with a wariness and restl essness in their manner, convinced me that they premeditated escape from the reserve, and for this reason, as well as for the deception they had practiced the day before, I caused their arrest, and confinement in the Guard House. A few hours afterward Gen. Crook visited us, and informed me that he wished to see all of the Indians as soon as Dr. Bendell arrived. Camp Date Creek, A.T. October 1st, 1872 Continued- Upon the arrival of Dr. Bendell on the afternoon of the 8th instant, Gen. Crook informed the Superintendent and myself, that there was evidence that several of the Indians upon this reserve, had been concerned in the murder of the passengers on the Wickenburg stage, last year, and in the perpetration of other atrocities, and that it was his intention to arrest such Indians. About the same time O—hat—che—com—a, unaccompanied by any number of his band, made his appearance. I do not deem it necessary to report herein, in detail, the events that followed while the Superintendent was present. Suffice it to say, that the condition of affairs, after the attempt to arrest, and at the time of the departure of Dr. Bendell was, as follows: Four Indians, count, 0-hat—che-com- a, Te—ye—ma-jor, Ar—ra—poot—yer, and Indian Jim, were incarc erated in the Guard House, and no other Indian (with the exception of an aged and infirm man) were to be seen upon the reservation. In the morning of that day, the number who had received rations were 398. These were all Apache Yumas. The band of 0-hat-che- corn-a, being all sbsent. During the night of the 8th ult., three of the Indians confined in the Guard House, attempted to escape through the canvass roof, and the soldiers firing upon them, Te-ye-ma-jor was killed. O—hat—che—com—a and Indian Jim, although both were severely wounded, succeeded in escaping in the darkness. On the following morning (the 9th ult.) I visited the rancherias of the Indians, and found them wholly deserted. I found four ponies, a considerable number of cooking utensils, a quantity of flour, and other articles, scattered here and there, abandoned by the Indians in their hasty flight. I took charge of the ponies, and have disposed of them as herein after indicated. An infant child (male) which in my absence, had been brought in to the Agency from one of the abandoned rancherias, was also taken charge of by me, and is still properly cared for. An aged Indian, badly wounded in the hip, was also found near the Camp, by the soldiers, and brought in for surgical treatment. On the 10th ultimo, some Indians came in, to Mr. Gilson, a citizen who resides upon the reservation about three miles from this Camp and who had displayed a white flag upon his ranche, and had a talk with him, seeking an explanation, why the Indians had been arrested on Sunday, and why they had been fired upon, and expressing a desire to return to the reservation. Mr. Gilson, after consultation with the Commanding Officer of the Camp Date Creek, A.T. October 1st, 1872 Continued- Post, and myself, started for Department Headquarters, with a report of the facts, and a request for instructions in the emergency. On the 11th ultimo, a few Indians came in, to the Agency, and stated that they were hungry, and that their children were crying for food. I save them rations, and told them that if they returned to and remained upon the reservation, they would be fed as heretofore. On the 12th ultimo, Jemaspie, with about twenty of his warriors, and two squaws, arrived, asking for rations, and also for the ponies above referred to, and for arms that they had lost. They also wished to take the wounded Indian, before mentioned, with them. Jemaspie was anxious to talk, especially about Iretaba and the affair of the 8th ultimo, but I told him that Gen. Crook was expected to arrive in a few days, and that a satisfactory explanation would then be made; and in the meantime, I would feed them as usual. I gave them rations, and the ponies, and permitted them to carry away the wounded Indian. On the 13th ultimo, about ten Indians came in, and I gave them rations. And on the same day Gen. Crook arrived, and a message was sent to the Indians that the General would receive them at the Post on the following morning. On the 14th ultimo, about 100 Indians came in and met the General. Rations were issued to them, and after they had prepared and eaten their food, but little time remained for the real objects of the gathering, since the Indians had come in at a late hour, and were desirous of returning to their Camp before dark, and the Council was adjourned to the 15th ultimo. On that day the Indians sent in word that the Chief’s wife was dead, and that they could not come in that day. On the 16th ultimo, Jemaspie, with twenty of his warriors came in and the following arrangement or treaty was agreed upon by Gen. Crook and the Chief, Jemaspie, with his people, to come back and remain upon the reservation; he is to permit his men to assist in punishing bad Indians; he is to be friendly with all the whites and their friends (from this last clause Jemaspie insisted on excepting Iretaba, Chief of the Mojaves): he is not to harbor or feed bad Indians, who are guilty of crimes against the whites or their friends, and for the present, the Indians are not to be absent from the reservation, except while assisting the troops in campaigns against hostile Indians. Camp Date Creek, A.T October 1st, 1872 Continued- On the 17th ultimo, 79 Indians (of whom, there were 60 warriors, 10 squaws, 8 boys and 1 girl) came in. They stated that quite a number of their Indians were sick, and that as soon as their people got well, they would move in upon the reserve. I told them that they had promised Gen. Crook, that they would come in at once, and they must do so, for if the soldiers found them in the mountains, they would kill them. I issued rations to them in bulk, but told them that they would not receive full rations until they came in with their families. An Indian was found near the Post this day, wounded in the right knee. He had had nothing to eat, except what he could pick up in the bush, since the 8th ultimo. The Indians carried him back with them on their return to their Camp. On September 18th, four Indians came in, to the Agency, and stated that one of Jemaspie’s children was sick, but that all the Indians would be in, on the next day. On the. 19th ultimo, Jemaspie, and twenty Indians came in for rations. The Chief was quite ill, and stated that ten of his Indians had died, and that the greater part of the remainder were sick. He also stated that he could not come in upon the reserve, for the present. On the 21st ultimo, two Indians came in and stated that the Indians would be in tomorrow (Saturday). On the 22nd ultimo, rio Indians having appeared, I sent out two Mexicans to seek their Camp. They returned with the report that nearly all of the Indians had left that morning, for the mountains, and evidently did not intend to return unless forced to do so. Up to the present date, nothing further has been developed. There are no Indians on the reservation, except the one confined in the Guard House, and the infant child above referred to, and at the present date, there appears little prospect of their speedy return. I am Sir, Very respectfully, Your obedient servant, J. Williams, U.S. Special Indian Agent.

20125, 20126. Office Supt. Ind. Affairs Arizona Terty., Prescott, Sept. 30th, 1872. Hon. F.A. Walker, Commissioner Indian Affairs, Washington- D.C. (letter)

Office Supt. md. Affairs Arizona Terty. Prescott Sept. 30th, 1872 Hon. F.A. Walker Commissioner Indian Affairs Washington- D.C. Sir: I have the honor to submit the following Report of General Information for the month of September, 1872. I returned to my office on the 9th inst., being delayed at San Francisco to perfect arrangements for supplying and feeding the Indians in accordance with Telegram from your office dated Aug. 5th, 1872. On my arrival at Arizona City, I was met by Dr. Wilbur, Agent for the Papagos who kindly assisted me in making the necessary arrangements to transport the Indians, who had returned with me from Washington, to their respective homes. It was my intention on my way from the Colorado River to Prescott, to stop at Camp Date Creek, interview the Apache Mojaves & Apache Yumas on reserve at that point, & through their representatives who had accompanied me to Washington; again to convey to them the good intentions of the Government, and present to their Chiefs (Ocho-ca-ma & Tho-mas-pai) the medals given me (through Gen. Howard) by the President for the above named Chiefs. On my arrival at Date Creek I was met by Gen’l. Crook, who informed me that he had come to Date Creek, to arrest Ocho—ca-ma, Chief of the Apache Mojaves for the murder of Col. Leihy late Suptd’t. md. Affrs. for this Territory and also to arrest three Indians who participated in the killing of Loring & party in the Wickenburg Stage Massacre; he (Gen’l. Crook) informing me that he had positive information, that the Indians he intended to arrest were guilty of the crime of which they were charged. I also learned from Agent Williams that the Indians (especially the Apache Mojaves) under the leadership of Ochoc a—ma, had behaved very bad during my absence from the Territory, had refused to obey the Agent, left the Reserve without permission and were insolent and defiant. I sent for the Chiefs, told them that I wanted to talk with them and would meet them that evening. On assembling in Council I found that but few Indians were on the Reservation; not more than fifty were present at the Council & the Chiefs refused to give me my information concerning the absentees. At the termination of my interview Gen’l. Crook attempted to arrest the guilty Indians, who resisted and in the fight one soldier was stabbed one Indian was killed and as I am informed several were afterwards reported wounded. The Indians stampeded from the Post & fled to the Mountains. Ocho-ca-ma was arrested & taken to the Guard-house but subs equently escaped. It is evident that the depredations committed in the valleys between Date Creek & the Colorado River previous to this affair, Office Supt. md. Affairs Arizona Terty. Prescott Sept. 30th, 1872 Continued- were committed by these Indians, and their absence from the Reservation was for no good purpose. During the month the Military have been active in scouting after these Indians; on the 27th ultimo (40) forty of them were killed & (10) ten taken prisoners. On the 30th ultimo (17) seventeen were killed at Squaw Peak (50) fifty miles from Prescott, on whose persons were found ration returns dated as issued up to the 29th ult. The Apaches at Camp Grant and Camp Apache, still remain on the Reserves; and I believe with judicious management will stay & conform to the rules established by the Government for their benefit. At Camp Verde the Indians have been coming & going. It is evident that they are anxious to receive rations, but not willing to remain within the Reservation limits. Mr. Jacobs having been relieved from the Agency at Camp Grant, is now en route to Camp Verde, and I hope in my next report to give more favorable accounts of the condition of affairs at that Reserve. The condition of the Pimas & Maricopas, Papagos, Mojaves, and Hualpais remains unchanged, the former are now enjoying the benefit of a fair average crop, and the Hualpais are assisting Gen. Crook as Scouts against the hostile Apache, and I anticipate no trouble from them. Ample arrangements for feeding the Indians at the various Reservations have been made and sufficient supplies are en route to guard against any contingency. I respectfully call the attention of the Hon. Commissioner to my letter of the 21st ult. regarding the purchase of Clothing and Blankets for the Indians; the weather in some parts of the Territory is very severe and unless these articles are purchased & issued, great suffering will necessarily follow. The Annuity Goods for the Pimas, Maricopas, Papagos, and Mojaves have all been sent, and are being issued to said Indians. I am Sir, Very respectfully, Your obd’t. servt., H. Bendell, Superintendent.

January 5, 2019

20119, 20020. Pacific Mil. Div., Asst. Adjt. Gen., Headquarters Department of Arizona, Prescott, September 18th, 1872 (letter)

Pacific Mu. Div. Asst. Adjt. Gen. Headquarters Department of Arizona Prescott, September 18th, 1872 Sir: I have the honor to report that for some time I have been satisfied who the parties were who committed the massacre of the stage passengers via Wickenburg last November, in which Mr. Loring and others lost their lives, and have been keeping as quiet about it as possible while using every endeavor to get the individual Indians into position so as to capture them. Having completed my arrangements, I left here on the 6th instant to meet Irataba, the Chief of the Mojaves with an Interpreter at Date Creek. The Chief was cognizant of the massacre and the parties who committed it, and was to identify such as were present at the council at Date Creek, so that the arrest could be made. On arriving at Date Creek I found that at least two thirds of the Indians, belonging on the reservation were absent from it, and that one band had left in a defiant manner, stating that they were not coming back, while others had left with the permission of the Agent to go to a certain place with the promise to come in whenever he sent for them, both of which promises they had failed to keep, and in addition several bands of stock were stolen from parties on the road from Date Creek to Ehrenberg, the trails leading to the country over which these Indians were roaming. The Indians who were at Date Creek seemed uneasy and suspicious, and in very bad temper, approaching with their arms and war paint. Some of the parties who had participated in the stage massacre were there, but very uneasy, and when the Indians were assembled I had some men detailed to make the arrests as soon as the Indians were identified. As they were designated the soldiers stepped up to arrest them, when one of the Indians friends, standing back of the soldiers, stabbed one of them in the back. A shot was fired, by whom I could hardly say, but I think it was by the soldier stabbed, and in an instant firing commenced on both sides, the Indians making for the hills. I made every effort, as did all the officers present to stop the firing, but it was all over in an instant. I returned to Prescott on the 9th, and on the 10th instant, received a despatch from the Commanding Officer of Camp Date Creek stating that the Indians wanted to talk with me and I went there at once. The Indians came in again and I promised them that I would grant amnesty to all the assassins, except one of the ring leaders who Headquarters Department of Arizona Prescott, September 18th, 1872 Continued- was still at large, as I had one in the guard house and two others were killed. Upon this, nearly all the Indians I had met the first time came in again and said if I would allow them to remain— they would be responsible for all the Indians who would come in. They did not deny their complicity with the stage massacre, but said there were a good many bad Indians among them, and that therefore they had been afraid to tell on each other, when depredations were committed. They promised that hereafter they would not only tell me when any depredations were committed, but they would go out with the troops if necessary, to punish the offenders. 0 As much as I regret that the arrest could not have been made without trouble, I am well satisfied that as it now transpires, the affair will be productive of good, as it is upon this basis and no other that you can rely upon Indians who come in upon our reservations. The applications must come from them, and not from us, they must sue to come in, and not feel all the time, that they confer a favor upon us by doing so. I am Sir very respectfully, Your obedient servant, George Crook, Lieut. Colonel 23rd Infantry, Brevet Major General, Commanding Department.

20114. Office U.S. Indian Agency, Camp Date Creek, A.T., September 7th, 1872, Lieut. W.J. Volkmar U.S.A., Commanding Officer (letter)

Office U.S. Indian Agency Camp Date Creek, A.T. September 7th, 1872 Lieut. W.J. Volkmar U.S.A. Commanding Officer Camp Date Creek, A.T. Sir: I have the honor to request that Te-ye-madeya (brother to 0- hot—che-ca-ma, Chief of Apache-Mohave Indians) and Indian Jim be confined in Guard House until the said Chief and his band return to this reserve. Very respectfully, Your obedient servant, 3. Williams, U.S. Indian Agent.

20112. The Arizona Miner, Prescott, Arizona Territory, September 7th, 1872. From Yuma County. Dr. H. Bendell, Superintendent of Indian Affairs (letter)

The Arizona Miner Prescott, Arizona Territory September 7th, 1872 FROM YUMA COUNTY. Dr. H. Bendell, Superintendent of Indian Affairs for this Territory, had arrived. He is coming to Prescott via Ehrenberg. John Wasson, of the Tucson Citizen, had passed through on his way to San Diego. Dr, R.A. Wilbur, Rev. Mr. Cook, and the Pima and Papago Indians, who recently visited Washington, had gone up the Gila road. The two Date Creek savages were awaiting a steamer to convey them to Ehrenberg.

20111. Wickenburg, A.T, September 6th, 1872, Commanding Officer, Camp Date Creek, Dear Sir, All of my stock at Culling's station... (letter)

Wickenburg, A.T. September 6th, 1872 Commanding Officer Camp Date Creek Dear Sir: All of my stock at Culling’s station was stolen last night, 18 head, by Indians. You will see by the letter I enclose from him that he thinks they were Date Creek Indians. If you could assist in pursuing them, you would confer a great favor, as all of the stock was taken with the balance. James Grant

20110. Culling's Well, September 5th, 1872, Mr. Pearson, The Indians have taken all the stock out of the corral last night... (letter)

Culling’s Wells September 5th, 1872 Mr. Pearson: The Indians have taken all the stock out of the corral last night, they left me on foot. If you can get some soldiers from Date Creek, we will follow them and see what Indians they are. I think they are Date Creek, as they went through Pen-hatchi-pet Pass towards New Water. Yours, Chas. Culling

January 3, 2019

20109. Hand-written letter dated August 31, 1872. (letter)

20105, 20106. Hd'qrs. Camp Date Creek, A.T., August 30th, 1872, Captain A.H. Nickerson 23rd Inf., A.A.A. General, Dept. of Arizona, Prescott, A.T. (letter)

Hd’qrs. Camp Date Creek, A.T. August 30th, 1872 Captain A.H. Nickerson 23rd Inf. A.A.A. General Dept. of Arizona Prescott, A.T. Captain: I have the honor to state that I arrived at this Post last night about 9 o’clock, having hasten forward, (and leaving my party to come on today) immediately upon learning of the death of Captain Dwyer, of which you have been advised. Though Lt. Bourke was at the Post in advance of me I deemed it proper that I should also be here as soon as possible. As I was aware of the important nature of Lt. Bourkes’ orders, and knew also that no officer was here except him, and he might wish to pursue his journey without delay, and as a great amount of public property would thus be left without an officer present, I considered it to be my duty to waive all other considerations and give my attention to this matter; although Lt. Bourke stated he would have remained had no one arrived. The circumstance were of such a peculiar nature (and perhaps the case has no precedent) that Lt. Bourke, in the name of the Dept. Commander, at once, authorized me to take command, (copy of letter enclosed) which I did; at the same time obtaining possession of the store house and safe keys, and I have since put everything in as secure a condition as practicable. The funeral of Captain Dwyer took place at 11 AM today, it being an absolute necessity, as the body was rapidly decomposing and becoming extremely offensive, so much so, that the Post Surgeon gave as his professional opinion that it was unadvisable, if not dangerous to assume the risks of generating contagion by deferring the interment. This I trust will satisfactorily explain what might otherwise have the appearance of undue haste. The Post Surgeon also states that a postm ortem examination was not necessary to discover anything relative to the death of Captain Dwyer of which he (the surgeon) was not already aware. Lt. Bourke left here immediately after the funeral. Before leaving he stated that when he should meet the troops, now on route from Ehrenberg, he would immediately send an officer if one could be spared to take command of this Post. Nothing as yet (4 PM) having been received in answer to dispatches forwarded yesterday morning to Dept. Hd’qrs., I have Hd’qrs. Camp Date Creek, A.T. August 30th, 1872 Continuedt hought. it best to send a courier with this, this evening. Should no orders arrive by tomorrow morning I shall send my party forward, and remain here until some instructions are received, as I do not wish Justice to be delayed. Whatever has been done in reference to this peculiar case, I trust may meet the approval of the Commanding General. I believe that the best interests of the service demanded the action that has been taken. Very respectfully, Your obedient servant, Charles Hay, 1st Lieut. 23rd Infantry.

20104. Date Creek, A.T., August 29th, 1872, General Adjutant, Dept. of Arizona, Captain: I have the honor to report that upon arriving... (letter)

Date Creek, A.T. August 29th, 1872 General Adjutant Dept. of Arizona Captain: I have the honor to report that upon arriving at this place, I found that Captain Dwyer, 5th Cavalry- Commanding Post, had suddenly died during the night of August 28th, and there being no other officer present, and no one to take charge, I assumed the responsibility of taking Command until the arrival of Lieut. Hay, 23rd Inf. Beyond seeing that desks, etc. were properly secured, I had no time to do anything except make preparations for the burial of the remains, rapidly decomposing from the effects of the sultry weather. Lieut. Hay arrived about six (6) hours after I did, and is now in Command having in his possession the keys, etc. of the deceased. I have the honor to be Sir, Very respectfully, Your obedient servant, 3ohn G. Bourke, 2nd Lieut. 3rd Cavalry. A true copy, Charles Hay, 1st Lieut. 23rd Infantry.

January 1, 2019

20096, 20097. Personal correspondence between Bill W. Smith and Barry Goldwater (February 11, 1992 and March 10, 1992) (letter)

Barry Goldwater P. 0. BOX 1601 SCOTTSDALE, ARIZONA 55252 February 11, 1992 Mr. Bill W. Smith Phoenix, AZ Dear Bill: When I returned home from your store this morning, I found your letter waiting. I’m very happy that your writing the story on the army post. It will be a terrific addition to the literature of Arizona. That part of Arizona has largly been neglected by historians, and I’m very happy for what your doing. I do know that my Grand Uncle Joe was hit by two bullets by raiding Apaches, although I didn’t know that Dr. Jones was traveling with them. He wore those two bullets as watch fobs for the rest of his life. My Grandfather Mike, was shot through the hat, with no damage. I do not have much in the way of specific information for you, but you’ve been working with Susie Sato, and in my book you can’t beat her. Keep i touch on this, and if I hear anything I’ll let you know. Barrij Goldwater March 10, 1992 Mr. Bill W. Smith Phoenix, AZ Dear Bill: P. 0. BOX 1601 SCOTTSDALE, ARIZONA 85252 Thank you for the copy of the Goldwater article by Dean Smith. I certainly do appreciate it, and thanks too for that article by James Cook. I think your on a real project. Camp Date Creek was just a hidden little waterway until you came along. When you chronicle the whole story, it will become one of the important places in Arizona’s wonderful history. The fact that both my grandfather, and grand-uncle, were both shot on that trip, that wound up in Date Creek, is very importanj, to both me and my family. Thank you for doing this, iA/s really a wonderful job for Arizona. S.

December 31, 2018

20088, 20089. Hand-written letter from Lieutenant F.H.E. Ebstein, dated 1872. (letter)

20085. The Army and Navy Journal, Volume IX, Number 29, Saturday, March 2nd, 1872. Colonel R.F. O'Beirne, U.S. Army, Commanding (letter)

The Army And Navy Journal Volume IX, Number 29 Saturday, March 2nd, 1872 Colonel R.F. O’Beirne U.S. Army, Commanding Sir: In reply to your request for a statement from me in regard to the medical and general treatment of William Kruger and Mollie Sheppard, while at this post, I have the honor to state that on the receipt of the information of the stage being attacked between Wickenburg and Ehrenberg, you ordered me to proceed without a moment’s delay, and render such assistance as the cases required. On my arrival at Wickenburg I found the only survivors— Mr. Kruger and Miss Sheppard, wounded; Kruger slightly, and the woman badly in the upper third right arm. Having been informed that no proper medical aid could be procured at the latter place, and in consultation with Captain Meinhold in regard to the matter, we came to the conclusion to remove them to a point near Camp Date Creek where they would receive proper care and attention. On our arrival at the post, it being near dark the woman was placed in the quarters occupied by the hospital matron, until such time as arrangements could be made for her removal to Mr. Gilson’s, on the reservation, (2½) miles from camp. On visiting her the morning after her arrival, I found her arm much swollen and inflamed, and so reported to you, when I was ordered to keep her there until such time as she could be removed without harm to herself to more comfortable quarters. Also, that I should admit William Kruger to hospital for treatment, etc., he refusing to go into hospital and preferring to remain at the matron’s with the wounded woman until such time as she had recovered sufficiently to be removed to Mr. Gilson’s where he accompanied her and where they remained until entirely recovered. I take pleasure in stating that every assistance was rendered me by the commanding officer of this post, and that every comfort that they could well have received was extended to them. I am sir, Very respectfully, Your obedient servant, D.J. Evans, Post Surgeon, CAMP DATE CREEK, A.T., January 27th, 1872.

20082, 20083, 20084. The Army And Navy Journal, Volume IX, Number 29, Saturday, March 2nd, 1872. (letter)

The Army And Navy Journal Volume IX, Number 29 Saturday, March 2nd, 1872 To the Editor of the Army and Navy Journal. Sir: I take advantage of your offer to publish any corrections of the letter which appeared in your issue of the 6th inst., over the signature of one “Wm. Kruger, chief clerk to Captain C.W. Foster, assistant quartermaster U.S. Army,” deeming it but my duty to contradict the statement which so unjustly reflects on an officer of my regiment. Being personally cognizant of everything connected with the attack on the Wickenburg stage, and the subsequent treatment of Mr. Kruger and Miss Sheppard by Captain R.F. O’Beirne, Twenty-first Infantry, commanding this post, I can only state to you that there is not a particle, not a shadow of foundation or truth in anything Mr. Kruger states in his letter, excepting the mere circumstances of the stage attack and the particulars of the untimely death of poor Mr. Loring. The facts in the case are simply these: Word was received at this post about 8 AM on Monday morning, November 6th, 1871, that the stage which left Prescott on the 4th for California, had been attacked about seven miles from Wickenburg, and that six persons had been killed and two wounded. Colonel O’Beirne at once sent Captain Charles Meinhold, Third Cavalry, with Lieutenant Simpson and some twenty odd enlisted men to the scene of the disaster, with instructions to follow the trail, and if possible discover the perpetrators of the attack, it being at the time a matter of grave doubt whether the attack was made by Indians or Mexicans. He also sent the post surgeon, Dr. Evans, to Wickenburg to assist in attending to the wounded. The latter returned on Tuesday the 7th, bringing with him the two wounded passengers Mr. William Kruger, and his fideu Achates Miss Mollie Sheppard, a Prescott prostitute and keeper of a house of ill-fame, with whom he was travelling. Mr. Kruger, who was but slightly wounded, was invited by Colonel O’Beirne to place himself under the doctor’s care at the post hospital, while Miss Sheppard was taken by the Doctor to the quarters of one of the laundresses. Everything was done for these people that it was possible to do. Mr. Kruger occupied the quarters of an officer who was temporarily absent from the post, and received every attention, while to Miss Sheppard word was sent by my wife, through the Doctor, that anything she might need in the way of wearing apparel was at her service. Mr. Kruger, however, seemed to be much offended that his companion was not shown more attention or taken into the quarters of one of the officers; and as far as I am personally concerned, I confess I would much rather have shown this attention to her than him, she being a poor unfortunate woman, while Mr. K. is an intelligent man, who had already so far degraded himself that Captain C.W. Foster, whose chief clerk he was, discharged him, and that his own brother- so at least I am informed by reliable partiesw ould not recognize or speak to him while at Ehrenberg. To the Editor of the Army and Navy Journal- Continued. There being no proper place in the post for Miss Sheppard, Colonel O’Beirne told the Doctor that as soon as she was well enough to be moved he would prefer if he (the Doctor) would have her removed to Mr. Gilson’s ranch, a comfortable house about two miles from the post, but on the reservation, where she would be in every way better off, and where the post surgeon could go every day to attend her. About a week after the arrival of the “two surviving cripples,” the Doctor reported the woman well enough to be moved, and they (Mr. Kruger of his own accord accompanied her) accordingly went to Mr. Gilson’s, where Dr. Evans attended them daily for several weeks and until they were well enough to leave. There is another point in Mr. Kruger’s statement that I desire to contradict. I quote from the letter published in the Journal of the 6th. “That I left my mark with the Indians, there is no doubt, because two Indians died from gun-shot wounds at Camp Date Creek Reservation; but the commanding officer refused to have the thing investigated, for fear he would find sufficient evidence that they were his pets- that is, Camp Date Creek Indians. At all events there is no doubt whatever that the outrage was committed by Indians, and that by Camp Date Creek Indians, those so-called friendly Indians whom Uncle Sam feeds These citizens tracked the Indians from the place of outrage to Camp Date Creek.” Being myself issuing commissary for the Indians here— ApacheY umas and Apache-Mojaves, each of whom comes daily to the post to draw his rations from me, and knowing from my intercourse with them each individual Indian, I can positively assure you that no Indian or Indians have ever died from gun-shot wounds on this reservation, and as on his arrival here, I particularly noticed Mr. Kruger’s pistol, from which not one single shot had been discharged, and which did not present the appearance of having been recently reloaded, I am very much inclined to think that he did not “leave his mark with the Indians.” I am furthermore prepared to testify to the fact that every effort was made by Colonel O’Beirne to discover if these so- called Camp Date Creek Indians were the guilty parties. The iron loop of a mail-sack was found with one of them, and at once sent to the postmaster at Wickenburg, A.T., for identification, who returned it saying that the mailsacks on the ill-fated stage were only cut open, but no part of them was missing; some legalt ender notes were found upon another and taken from him, but were afterward identified by Mr. Charles B. Genung, of Peeples’ Valley, as money he had paid this Indian for work done upon his ranch; every effort, in fact, was made, but nothing was elicited to fix the crime upon the Indians here. Not only this, but Colonel O’Beirne also went in person to Wickenburg and collected To the Editor of the Army and Navy Journal- Continued. the effects of the deceased, which he forwarded to Lieutenant Wheeler, Corps of Engineers, from which he received a very handsome letter in reply. In regard to the statement that the trail led from the place of attack to this post, I have only to say that Captain Meinhold, Third Cavalry, went to the place of attack and took up the trail, which took the direction of this post for about one mile and then turned southeast and continued in almost the opposite direction from this place. I have already taken up more of your space than I first intended, for the unblemished and Christian character of Captain and Brevet Lieutenant-Colonel R.F. O’Beirne is to well known throughout the Army, to be stained with the mire thus thrown at him by Mr. Kruger, but as his (Kruger’s) letter has been extensively published and commented upon by the press, I merely wish, in justice to a brother officer, to correct this foul slander. Fred H.E. Ebstein, Second Lieutenant Twenty-first Infantry. CAMP DATE CREEK, A.T., January 26th, 1872.

20080, 20081. The Army and Navy Journal, Volume IX, Number 29, Saturday, March 2nd, 1872. To the Editor of the Army and Navy Journal (letter)

The Army And Navy Journal Volume IX, Number 29 Saturday, March 2nd, 1872 To the Editor of the Army and Navy Journal. Sir: My attention has been called to a letter addressed to William C. Peckham, Esq., Trinity Building, New York and signed by William Kruger, chief clerk to Captain C.W. Foster, assistant quarterm aster U.S. Army, pretending to give an account of the massacre near Wickenburg, in which Mr. Fred Loring and others were killed. Were I to consult my own inclinations and disregard the wishes of my friends, I would pass this letter by with the contempt it deserves. It is charitable to suppose that Mr. Kruger must be insane, for it is only on this theory that one can account for the falsehoods which his letter contains. Without going into details I positively assert that every statement Mr. Kruger has made in that letter as regards my treatment of him and “Miss Sheppard” and my conduct in the investigation of the sad affair, is false in every particular, and that no one is better aware of this than Mr. Kruger. The report of the attack on the stage reached me some twenty- two hours after its occurrence. I immediately ordered Captain Meinhold and Lieutenant Simpson, with a detachment of Troop B, Third Cavalry, to proceed to the point of attack, to pursue the assassins, and if not successful in overtaking them, to find out if possible from whence they came. I also sent the post surgeon to attend to the wounded. Captain Meinhold in his report states that the tracks, which he followed some twenty-five miles from where the stage was attacked, after leading for some distance towards this post, turned off in an opposite direction. There is not one particle of evidence to show that the Indians on the Date Creek Reservation had anything to do with the massacre. The statement that two Indians died from gunshot wounds on this reservation shortly after the sad occurrence is false; indeed I am informed by an officer who examined Mr. Kruger’s revolver on his arrival at this post that there was not one shot fired out of it. With regard to the charge of inhumanity towards Mr. Kruger and “Miss Sheppard,” I prefer to let others speak, and forward you herewith, statements from Lieutenant Ebstein, Twenty-first Infantry, and Dr. Evans, the surgeon of the post, which show conclusively that every comfort and attention that could readily be shown them was freely extended. I am loath to add, but simple justice compels me to statew ith the view of showing the character and standing of Mr. Kruger, that “Miss Sheppard” who was travelling under his To the Editor of the Army and Navy Journal- Continued. protection and to whom he so feelingly alludes, is a notorious prostitute (not—withstanding, I believe her to be much the better character of the two) who has for a long time, I am informed, enjoyed the questionable care and patronage of Mr. Kruger. With great respect, Your obedient servant, R.F. O’Beirne, Captain Twenty-first Infantry. CAMP DATE CREEK, ARIZONA, January 27th, 1872.

December 29, 2018

20072, 20073, 20074. The Army And Navy Journal, Volume IX, Number 21, Saturday, January 6th, 1872. Twenty-first Infantry. (letter)

The Army And Navy Journal Volume IX, Number 21 Saturday, January 6th, 1872 Twenty-first Infantry. From Boston a correspondent of the New York Times sends the following letter from one of the survivors of the Loring massacre, giving an account of that massacre, and reflecting on the conduct of one of the officers of this regiment with reference to it. We publish the letter as it bears a responsible signature, but shall be glad to publish any correction of its statements: Ehrenberg, A.T., December 9th, 1871. William G. Peckham, Esq. Trinity Building, New York Dear Sir: In acknowledging the receipt of your letter of November 16th, 1871, I am pleased to be able to give you an account of the death of my friend Loring, who was well known to me and whose untimely death is deeply regretted by me. We left Fort Whipple, near Prescott, Arizona Territory, on Saturday, November 4th, in the best of health and spirits. To be sure, the stage was rather crowded, but being all of such good temper we had a real nice time, Loring being the most lively of us all, anticipating a speedy return to his friends East. Well he retained his inside seat until we reached Wickenburg, on Sunday morning, November 5th, 1871, when, after leaving there, he preferred to have an outside seat, to which I most decidedly objected; but he insisted on being outside for a short time. I had two revolvers and he had none; in fact, no arms whatever. He rejected my offer of a revolver, saying at the same time, “My dear Kruger, we are now comparatively safe. I have travelled with Lieutenant Wheeler for nearly eight months, and have never seen an Indian.” Well we rolled on until about 11 AM, when the fatal attack was made. The first warning I had was the warning of the driver, who cried “Apaches! Apaches!” At the same moment the Indians, who lay concealed, fired the first volley, killing poor Loring, the driver, and the other outside passenger, a Mr. Adams. They killed also the off lead horse and wounded the other lead horse. The horses very much frightened, then ran forward about twenty yards, when they came to a sudden stop. At the same time Loring fell off the stage and so the other passenger. At the same moment the Indians fired the second volley from three sides- the both sides and rear— not more than four or five yards from the stage, killing Mr. Shohoim, one of the inside passengers, and wounding Miss Sheppard, myself and a Mr. Salmon, of Lieutenant Wheeler’s party. The latter one was mortally wounded and fell out of the stage, and crawled away, but was finally captured by the Indians, scalped and otherwise mutilated. The only one not then wounded Letter from Army and Navy Journal— Continued. was Mr. Hamel, of Lieutenant Wheeler’s party. Both he and myself commenced immediately firing. Each one fired six shots. Not having any more ammunition I ceased firing. The Indians then disappeared behind the bushes. But what a terrible spectacle it was to see the six dead bodies in plain sight! Loring was lying right under my very eyes, not yet dead, but suffering, apparently, terribly. He was shot through his left temple, his right eye, and his lungs. He suffered for about four minutes, but I am positive that he died before I made my escape. Knowing that it would be useless to attempt to escape until the Indians would come back to plunder the stage, I remained perfectly quiet, having in the mean time ascertained that Miss Sheppard was yet alive, but badly wounded. She succeeded in getting a loaded revolver from one of the killed passengers, which she gave to me. I then told her to keep cool and be ready to run as soon as I would give the signal. Well, in about six minutes of terrible suspense I saw the Indians slowly creeping toward the stage. I counted and saw plainly fifteen Indians all dressed in blue soldiers’ trousers. When they came within five yards of the stage I jumped up, yelled and fired at them. The woman, at the same time, yelled also, and we succeeded admirably in driving them off for the time being, and got time to leave the stage. Before I left the stage I cried out as loud as I possibly could if any one was left alive, but only Mr. Adams answered; but he was mortally wounded and could not even move his hands or feet, so I had to leave him to his fate. He was afterward found with his throat cut and otherwise mutilated. The Indians afterward followed me for about five miles, and I had a running fight with them until I fell in with the “buck-board.” I had to carry the wounded woman for over two miles in my left arm. I myself received one shot through the right armpit, coming out on the shoulder, and two shots in my back. The woman also had three shots, one dangerous. How I could escape with my life, and be able to save the life of Miss Sheppard, is more than I can account for. That I left my mark with the Indians, there is no doubt, because two Indians died from gun—shot wounds at Camp Date Creek Reservation; but the commanding officer refused to have the thing investigated, for fear he would find sufficient evidence that they were his pets- that is Camp Date Creek Indians. At all events there is no doubt whatever that the outrage was committed by Indians, and that by Camp Date Creek Indians, those so-called friendly Indians whom Uncle Sam feeds. After the news reached Wickenburg, we were brought to Wickenburg after sixteen hours of terrible suffering and agony. I stopped at the place of attack and closed the eyes of all my poor travelling companions. Loring, poor boy, was not mutilated, but looked calm and peaceful, excepting his fearful wounds through the head. He wore soldiers’ clothing. His hat is in my possession now; if you wish it you can have it. Loring and four of his companions in Letter from Army and Navy 3ournal- Continued. fate were decently buried the next day, Monday, November 6th, 1871, in nice coffins. I saw them buried. The other man who got scalped was buried on the road. Mr. Sexton, of the Vulture Mill, at Wickenburg, attended to the funeral. Rest assured that our friend Loring had a decent funeral. Peace be with his ashes. I forwarded everything belonging to Loring to Lieutenant Wheeler, excepting his hat, which you can have should you desire it. There are four bullet—holes through the same. What Loring lost I don’t profess to know. I know, I lost everything but my life. The Indians got, to my certain knowledge, about twenty-five thousand dollars- nine thousand dollars belonging to me and Miss Sheppard. There is not a particle of doubt in my mind that the attacking party were Indians. I have known Indians since the last five years, and cannot be mistaken; besides, all indications show that they were Indians. Every citizen here will swear to it, because these citizens tracked the Indians from the place of outrage to Camp Date Creek. But the commanding officer, Captain O’Beirne, Twenty-first Infantry, not only allowed the Indians to go unpunished, but also refused me, Miss Sheppard, the two surviving cripples, shelter. Yes sir; he ordered us off his reservation, and I wish to heaven you would publish this act of inhumanity in your New York papers. Please show this letter to Mr. Loring, Boston, Mass., who wrote to me the same time you did. I am sir, Very truly yours, William Kruger Chief Clerk to Captain C.W. Foster, Q.M., U.S.A.